Features/Meson/Design

Rules.mak has gotten insane, let's get rid of it!

More seriously, the current build system causes clutter in the toplevel Makefiles, and it makes simple tasks harder than they should be. For example, each executable in contrib/ has to touch three files: Makefile, Makefile.objs and contrib/*/Makefile.objs.

Meson has several advantages that directly matter for QEMU including the following:

• build definitions in a very readable and user friendly DSL, which supports looping and conditions
• ability to introspect the build definitions so that you can find out what is built without building it (the DSL is not Turing complete and most objects in it are immutable, so it cannot be abused that much :))
• support for a non-recursive build from per-subdirectory input (similar to Makefile.objs)
• strong checking of prerequisites when Meson is run, so that it's usually unnecessary to debug whatever files Meson generates
• ease of distributing a full copy of Meson to support distros that ship an older version (no dependencies apart from Python 3.5).

The transition is designed around the following goals:

• the build system should make it trivial to do trivial things; easy to do things that are a matter of cut-and-paste from something that already exist; possible to do everything else.
• it should remain trivial to do things that used to be trivial, and most "make" invocations should be kept the same at least until everything is converted (and we can perhaps declare a flag day). It should not become harder to do things that are a matter of cut-and-paste.
• it should be possible to modify meson.build without knowing QEMU specific details, and that should be already possible now at the beginning of the transition (to avoid creating technical debt). This means keeping the magic confined in Makefile rules and external scripts, while having a pretty plain meson.build.

A PoC was posted in June 2019. It includes a program called "ninjatool" that replaces ninja for the few cases where meson invokes it directly (ninja -t compdb, ninja -t clean) and that also is able to convert build.ninja files to Make syntax. Because of this, it is trivial to have make build products that depend on meson build products. Therefore bottom up is the natural direction for the conversion.

This fits in a generic plan to drop Makefile magic in favor of build rule generators written in high-level languages. For example, in order to keep make check-like rules working, we could generate Makefile rules from the output of meson introspect --tests. This, together with the use of ninja2make also gives us an escape mechanism in case we want to do something that Meson cannot (yet) do, or doesn't do the way we want it.

The alternative of having two parallel build systems was rejected. This would introduce extra work for people not involved in the conversion, and the risk of bitrotting one of the two build systems is large.

Issues

Meson

• Support a NINJA environment variable (fixed in 0.51.0)
• Kconfig Module (included in 0.51.0 but still named "unstable-kconfig", should be stabilized before QEMU switches to meson)
• new module "sourceset" to match source file lists against configuration data (included in 0.51.0)
• Script found by find_program() does not end up in dependencies (fixed in 0.51.0)
• do not include host environment in test/benchmark introspection data (fixed in 0.51.0)
• Target file name must not contain a path separator - makes it impossible to generate e.g. audio/trace.h. Ideas:
  • add something that behaves like "generator()" but generates custom_targets
  • generate files like trace/trace-audio.h and add one-line forwarding header files so that we can keep the #include "trace.h" idiom.
• Meson handles generated headers more sanely, without requiring Makefile to depend on them. However we need to check that files are not rebuilt too often if we don't have timestamp files. See also here.
• We need to know where our modules end up in the build dir to be able to have a working dev version of QEMU

QEMU

• Deprecate in-tree build? Meson only supports out-of-tree.

Status

• PoC: https://patchew.org/QEMU/1560165301-39026-1-git-send-email-pbonzini@redhat.com/
• Next PoC should:
  • move ninjatool generation to meson.build
  • convert libqemuutil.a, trace, QAPI
• Further phases:
  • ship Meson as a submodule
  • convert emulators and other tools
  • convert qemu-ga
  • convert tests
  • convert configure tests - until then, meson.build can read in the contents of config-host.mak